opinions
The Arctic Mayors’ Forum:
Dual-Use or Multi-Benefit
This is an op-ed written by an external contributor. All views expressed are the writer's own.
Opinion piece by the Arctic Mayors’ Forum, co-authored with the Mayors of Harstad, Inuvik, Luleå, Sermersooq, and Utqiaġvik: Else Marie Stenhaug, Peter Clarkson, Carina Sammeli, Avaaraq Olsen, and Asisaun Toovak.
Let’s be clear: in the event of an armed conflict in the High North, many Arctic communities would find themselves in the direct line of fire. Some host military bases. Others are home to infrastructure, resources, or transport corridors of strategic importance. Already today, communities across the region are experiencing increased militarization.
As Arctic states seek to strengthen their sovereignty and defense capabilities, large investments are on the horizon and, quite literally, more boots are on the ground.
But if the Arctic is to become a focus for major defense spending, the question is not simply what infrastructure gets built. The questions are who benefits, who decides, and do these investments strengthen communities as much as they strengthen states.
The EU's new Arctic Strategy shares an understanding of the role communities play. It describes a secure, peaceful and resilient Arctic as essential to prosperous Arctic communities. It promises to promote dual-use capabilities that benefit both local communities and wider Arctic and European security.
And, significantly, it acknowledges that strong communities and resilient infrastructure are the "bedrock" of preparedness.
Defense spending is helping unlock infrastructure projects
Arctic communities welcome this shift. Local resilience has long been treated as the concern of a few. In reality, it is a strategic necessity for a peaceful and secure Arctic and increasingly, these discussions are being framed through the lens of dual-use infrastructure.
Paying the bills
In some parts of the Arctic, defense spending is helping unlock infrastructure projects that have spent decades on the drawing board. One example is the Mackenzie Valley Highway in Canada's Northwest Territories. This 800-kilometre all-season gravel road would connect the Town of Inuvik, on the East Channel of the Mackenzie Delta, to other regional hubs.
The result would be shorter supply chains, improved access to healthcare, new opportunities for local economic development – and a statement of Canada’s sovereignty in the territory.
The Government of Canada recently announced that it would cover both the construction and maintenance costs of the project until 2031, a commitment the Territories have sought for decades.
Dual-use infrastructure, it seems, can open federal wallets faster and wider. A potential gamechanger for Arctic communities: "Everything is dual-use," argues Inuvik Mayor Peter Clarkson. Roads, airports, ports, communications systems and energy infrastructure all serve multiple purposes. As Clarkson notes, "it is impossible to set up a military base without a community around it."
Thus, if infrastructure investments are to succeed, they must strengthen everyday life as well as national security. Better transport links are one example. Other needs include housing, water and wastewater systems, healthcare, emergency services and recreational facilities.
The shadow side
However, Arctic communities also have good reasons to approach today's investments with caution. Across the region, military infrastructure has too often been built to serve strategic interests while leaving local residents and the environment to bear the long-term consequences.
In Greenland, entire communities were forcibly relocated at the height of the Cold War. Many are still seeking recognition and compensation today. In Utqiaġvik, Alaska's northernmost town, the legacy of military development remains visible. During the Second World War, the U.S. military established a radar site and airstrip to support Arctic defense operations.
Those facilities stand as reminders of the region's strategic importance. They also serve as reminders of environmental contamination that followed. “The North Slope is the size of Iceland, it’s where we subsist and hunt. But the military waste and the leaked chemicals continue to affect our land, water sources and hunting grounds,” says Asisaun Toovak, Mayor of Utqiaġvik.
For many local and Indigenous communities, military expansion therefore carries memories of displacement, exclusion and decisions imposed from outside. Decolonializing military spending thus requires moving away from a top-down approach and working with communities as partners.
Cooperation between the municipality and the Arctic Command
"Two years ago, we saw a lot of resistance in Nuuk towards seeing military personnel in the streets. There was a fear of becoming a target. But now the military presence has helped us to feel more secure," says Avaaraq Olsen, Mayor of Sermersooq, Greenland's largest municipality, which includes the capital Nuuk.
A key reason for the positive shift has been cooperation between the municipality and the Arctic Command. Together, they developed practical protocols for how military personnel should operate in the city. It turns out, a jogging tour in civilian tights can make a real difference.
More risks than invasion
Military conflict, however, is not the most immediate threat many Arctic communities fear. As climate change accelerates and the region becomes increasingly connected to global markets, communities are dealing with coastal erosion, thawing permafrost, wildfires, infrastructure failures but also disruptions to critical services, hybrid attacks and grey-zone threats.
Preparedness has therefore become multifaceted, and spending needs to reflect this. Infrastructure designed around community needs will, by extension, also support military operations across the land, sea, air, and cyber domains.
But what happens when those interests no longer align?
Keeping the lights on
"Society must keep functioning throughout a crisis. That is our responsibility as municipalities. We must take care of our people, whether during an armed conflict or another emergency," emphasizes Carina Sammeli, Mayor of Luleå, Sweden.
Infrastructure built in times of peace will be expected to serve civil society, industry and the military during times of crisis. Yet when resources become scarce, difficult questions emerge. Who takes priority? Will homes remain heated? Will critical public services continue uninterrupted? Will industries be asked to reduce production? In other words: how "multi-use" is the infrastructure really?
These are questions that should be answered before investments are made. Perhaps it is therefore time to develop a clearer Arctic understanding of what dual-use means in practice and to establish some clear criteria for evaluating military-linked infrastructure projects: Do projects create local jobs? Do they close critical infrastructure gaps?
Are environmental impacts addressed throughout the project's lifecycle? And will communities continue to benefit if military priorities change in the future?
Stronger together
These are not small questions. The decisions being made today will shape Arctic communities, infrastructure systems and defense capabilities for decades to come. The time to get it right is now and as Else Marie Stenhaug, Mayor of Harstad, Norway, reminds us: "No one is big enough to solve these challenges alone. No one gets through a crisis alone."
They become multi-benefit
That means learning from both successes and mistakes, sharing experiences across borders, and developing investment pathways that reflect Arctic realities and local needs. If new investments leave communities with stronger public services, safer transport links, more housing, better emergency response and greater local capacity, they can strengthen both security and resilience.
They become multi-benefit. If they do not, the Arctic risks repeating familiar mistakes.
Some AI has been used as help with this text.