opinions

Arne O. Holm comments:

Tromsø State Fund Could Secure Norway’s Nussir Copper Mine

Gruslagt industriområde ved kysten med rødt bygg, steinmasser og fjell i bakgrunnen.
The new owners of the Nussir mine are causing justified concern.

Commentary: Nearly 20 years after Øystein Rushfeldt began the work of opening a copper mine in what was then the municipality of Kvalsund, Northern Norway, the company is once again at the center of a storm. The attacks stem from a combination of security policy concerns and general opposition to mining. But there is a solution.

Published Modified

This is a comment written by a member of the editorial staff. All views expressed are the writer's own.

If we set aside the opposition to mining—noting that, after 18 years, the mine has secured the necessary permits and is welcomed by its current host municipality, Hammerfest—what remains are the potential geopolitical and security-related implications of the impending sale.

Warranted concern

The sale of the mine to a company controlled by a Russian national—with owners registered in the opaque tax haven of the Cayman Islands—has justifiably drawn attention and prompted critical questions. Furthermore, one of the board members, Mike Pompeo, was among the most staunchly nationalist hawks during Donald Trump’s first presidential term.

Questioning the security implications of allowing strategically important minerals to pass out of national control is both necessary and appropriate. In a previous commentary, I myself questioned the wisdom of such a controversial ownership structure entering the Arctic mining industry.

The problem, however, arose long before the Russian Artem Volynet and the Russian-British company AMC put 2.3 billion NOK on the table to acquire the mine—a mine that, in addition to decades of copper production, also contains other valuable and strategically important metals.

Heading toward the precipice

A lack of willingness—from both the private and public sectors—to invest is slowly pushing Finnmark county toward the precipice. It is hardly surprising that there is no appetite to commit private capital to industrial ventures in a county bordering Russia—a region that struggles to attract skilled labor, suffers from failing municipal finances, and contends with an electrical grid and a healthcare system that are failing to deliver.

The strategy is merely a piece of paper.

Especially since the state is failing to take the lead and pave the way, In Kirkenes, the new owners are requesting 400 NOK in state subsidies to launch new mining operations at A/S Sydvaranger. By doing so, they hope to attract the necessary private capital—whether domestic or international.

The buyers of Nussir are paying 2.3 billion NOK and stand to reap super-profits, provided the mine delivers on its promises. No other parties submitted bids, and the Norwegian state showed no interest.

The current situation reveals that Norway’s so-called "mineral strategy" is, in reality, nothing more than a piece of paper—and paper cannot move waste rock in a mine.

State-owned fund

While this is taking place, the state has established a state-owned fund in Tromsø, Northern Norway, with an initial capital of 15 billion NOK—potentially reaching as much as 30 billion, should it prove successful.

State-owned investment capital does, in fact, exist in the North, and one might easily assume that this is part of an effort to strengthen industry and business in Northern Norway.

However, the fund—which is owned by the Government Pension Fund Norway (Folketrygdfondet)—has an entirely different purpose. It is mandated to invest exclusively in smaller, publicly listed companies across the Nordic region. The fact that it is based in the North provides absolutely no industrial benefit to the region.

With a different mandate, the fund could have acquired ownership stakes in both Nussir and Sydvaranger mines, while still retaining an investment capital of just over 12.5 billion NOK.

In this way, we would have addressed essential security policy considerations, secured national control over strategic minerals, and invested in jobs and expertise in Finnmark.

Kinder Surprise Egg

A political and industrial "Kinder Surprise Egg."

It has absolutely no industrial effect in the North.

Instead, the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Fisheries is currently working feverishly to ensure that the new owners of Nussir do not pose a threat to national security.

If the government fails to do so, a parliamentary majority could block the sale of Nussir, effectively sending the mining project back to square one—leaving it unable to supply products that this same parliamentary majority considers vital to Europe’s future.

Should the sale go through, the Nussir case is all but certain to land on the Minister of Trade and Industry’s desk again at some point in the future. International investment funds typically operate with a short-term investment horizon; eventually, they will look to cash in their profits, divest, and make way for new owners.

Which, in turn, will open up a discussion about what became of the Norwegian mineral strategy. Not to mention our national preparedness.

There is a solution to be found in Tromsø, where state capital exists that could be put to proper use.

Instead of picking stocks in small companies on the Stockholm stock exchange.

Powered by Labrador CMS